Powerplays, shocks, West Indies, Strauss and choking

Posted: September 28, 2009 in england, south africa, Sri Lanka, West Indies
Tags: , , , , , , , ,

No, my silence hasn’t been due to Sri Lanka being on the brink of elimination from the Champion’s Trophy, but due to an excess load of work, I haven’t been able to post. However, that hasn’t stopped me from keeping track of the Champion’s Trophy, so here’s what’s been happening.

The fact that England are the 2nd team to have qualified to the semis have baffled everyone, including yours truly. After getting a right-royal drubbing from Australia and nearly got swept away 7-0, I did not, in my wildest dreams, expect England to play like they were the best team in ODIs ever.

Morgan, who looked a bit out of his depth, sizzled. Shah suddenly remember how to run and Collingwood realised that he could play big shots with the ‘Blockingwood’ bat!

As for SL…sigh! I really had high expectations for SL for the first time in a world tournament because I felt we had the best batting order in nearly 3 years. Our middle order had always been a problem. However, in Samaraweera, Kandamby and Mathews, we had a middle order which could bail us out in case Jayasuriya and Dilshan both failed. However….I just can’t point the finger to what went wrong…

West Indies haven’t done a bad job at all, bringing both matches really close till the class of the better team shone.

As for South Africa…..dear, oh dear, do I have to mention the C-word again? I just don’t know what’s up with them. If I’m not mistaken, they are the only team to have a full-time mental conditioner but they still can’t get into a final, let alone win one. I just get the feeling that the Saffers are mentally weak! Full stop. It’s the same situation with the Bangladeshis. They have a good load of talent, but just don’t have the mental fortitude to win consistently.

IMO, Andrew Strauss was wrong in denying the South African skipper a runner. Yes, it is all about proper conditioning of the body, but still, it can be quite energy – sapping to bat 40+ overs.

I can understand ruthlesness, but there is something called the ‘Spirit of Cricket’. Yes, this has been a sticky point in many instances as it is hard to define what exactly this ‘Spirit’ is. Let me give you a simple definition:

The Spirit of Cricket is playing the game in a hard, yet fair way

It means that you play aggressive cricket, but play fair. I wouldn’t have recalled Mathews if I were Strauss. It was Mathews’ fault that he was ball – watching. There was no way Onions could have possibly seen him coming (he would have had to sprout eyes on the back of his head). However, Smith did nothing wrong and all player suffer cramps when playing for so long. It will become a sticky point when some of his own players, most notably Owais Shah (who does have a tendency to cramp quickly), suffer cramps and need runners.

On the subject of Powerplays, I’d like to refer to the first match of the competition, between Sri Lanka and South Africa.

The scenario is this: Dilshan is carting the ball around the park and the mandatory 10 over powerplay has finished. As the fielding captain, do you take the powerplay or not?

IMO, it should be a sure NO! The simple reason is, he’s obviously finding the boundaries easily because there aren’t enough fielders at the boundary. We all know that Dilshan doesn’t hit big like, say, a Morgan or a Symonds, but he hits them fast. Perhaps, the presence of more fielders on the boundary rope can stifle the runs and, perhaps, even get a wicket. I would’ve taken the Powerplay after Dilshan was dismissed.

SL also erred in not taking their powerplay immediately. It didn’t cost them in the end, but I feel that Sanga should’ve taken the powerplay immediately after SA’s one. It was clear that Dilshan wanted the pace in order to play his shots and Smith wasn’t willing to bring in the spinners during the powerplays, so we could’ve milked a lot more runs.

Well, that’s that! The CT has been an unqualified success in that it makes life difficult for a team when they have lost just once! It does bring me to the question which Mike Holmans raised in the Different Strokes blog in Cricinfo. Why do we hate the CT so much when the World Cup is such an elongated piece of shit?


PS – Just saw that there’s been a mad jump in the number of unique visitors to this blog in the last 3 days…can anyone enlighten me why? 🙂

  1. Sachintha says:

    Saffers didn't choke this time. They didn't get close enough to choke this time. They just got ass raped this time by us AND England. Things can't get better.LOLAnd about Smith incident, I think he was right there. You can't get a runner for cramps. I mean, even if you don't, after scoring 140 you can't run properly most of the time. So if he were to get a runner, surely the new guy would have turned ones into twos and twos into threes. Is that fair?

  2. Cricket Tragic says:

    @SachOn the subject of SA, there was a absolute gem by Andy Zaltzman from the Confectionary Stall blog in Cricinfo, where he said they lost against SL so that they can get rid of the choke early! hehee!On Smith, yes, it is a bit cloudy. However, thinking abt it yesterday after I posted this, I remember that Jayasuriya always cramps once he gets a century, regardless of whether he gets it in the 27th over or in the 47th, but I don't remember him ever calling for a runner!But, maybe, Strauss is right. You shouldn't call for a runner just because u have cramps, its k if u've twinged a hamstring or something!Anywayz, the Spirit of Cricket is a very fuzzy concept and it really is difficult to say whether something is right or wrong! 😦

  3. Baiju Nair says:

    SA should change their mentality if they are going to win global tournaments. Why didn't they sent a pinch hitter ahead of Kallis still baffles me…

  4. Cricket Tragic says:

    @Baiju NairSambit Bal has a gem of an article on Cricinfo which gives the reason for their failures at multi-team tournaments…the fact that they never think of changing their plan even if it is absolutely necessary..

  5. Sreehari says:

    HiI have started a blog under the title http://cricketcoloumn.blogspot.com which I’d be updating every now and then. Pls visit my blog and incase u find the blog really interesting have a link on your blog. I’ve added your blog under the title “Off Cutter”.Have a great day


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s